We did it.
We took the front off of Addie's crib.
A few days after I wrote
this post, I got online to see where we could purchase the toddler rail that would convert Addie's crib. What I found was that it is no longer available. Lovely. The most popular brand of the fold down rails on Amazon was all sold out and not expected to be back in stock until the summer. All of the stores in our area that carry them were also sold out. I finally found one that was in stock and not terribly expensive. Well, that one was too big for her crib. It was made for twin to queen size beds, and we did not feel comfortable with the way it fit on her crib frame. But the bright side is that we now have a rail for when we convert her bed to a full size one in a couple of years. Next up was more research on Amazon. I finally found one that was actually made for cribs and placed the order. This one actually attaches to the frame of the crib and barely budges when she sits up with her back against it.

It looks extremely small in this picture but it's actually the perfect size for Addie's crib. There is also three layers of blankets folded up next to the bed, with more padding on the right side where the space is bigger. I've thought about maybe even putting the cute bumpers that came with her crib bedding that we never really got to use back on. Lately, she's been sleeping with her beloved Pluto, one of the lovies pictured (usually the brown & pink one), and her blanket.
The rail arrived on a Saturday afternoon after she had already taken a nap. We decided to just go for it & try it out that night. Bedtime went fairly well, especially since she refused to get out of the bed by herself. I would say she made herself comfortable, wouldn't you?
Around 2am the first night, she woke up crying and tried to stand up in bed. Thankfully, I made it into her room (which is right across the hall) before she did. I held her for a couple of minutes, then put her back down and she slept til the morning. I was cautiously optimistic that our first night hadn't gone too terrible, but I also wasn't naive to think it would stay this way.
She stood up during her nap the next afternoon, but quickly sat back down when she realized there wasn't anything in front of her to hold on to. That night, bedtime went just like the night before, and she was asleep by the time I shut her door. But around 2am, she stood up again, this time she was facing the wall and tried to lean against the rail. I was so scared she would fall backwards over the rail. Of course, this made me second guess our decision to transition from the crib. I thought we had rushed it and should have just waited until after her surgery to see how she was going to do in the cast.
But that was it.
Since then, we really haven't had any problems. We've had a few hiccups here and there with her waking in the middle of the night; a few times she wasn't able to soothe herself back to sleep. She hasn't tried to get out of the bed herself...well, until this morning. I noticed on the monitor that she was awake but she was still just laying in bed. About five minutes later I went into her room to get her, and she was standing on top of the blankets holding onto the side of the crib with a big grin on her face.
We may be turning her door knob around so she won't lock herself in her room pretty soon...